Real Astbury Girrrl
Member
Posts: 132
Registered: 3-12-2003
Member Is Offline
Mood: fuckin bored
|
|
If Ian was ever replaced.....
How would we feel if The Cult, i.e. Duffy, Morrison, Sorum decided to go on as The Cult except have someone replace Ian. Personally, I think I would
vomit.
I am just imagining how a hard core Doors fan must feel perhaps? I am glad Ian is so well received. He deserves it since he is SO good.
But I can NEVER EVER imagine any replacing him in The Cult. That would be seriously depressing.
|
|
|
Inka
Member
Posts: 151
Registered: 1-9-2003
Location: Poland
Member Is Offline
Mood: ColdWhiteLight
|
|
I think it's hard to say. I've been a Doors' fan for a little bit longer that Cult's. But for me they always were a legend. Ray, Robby and John didn't
play, Jim's dead. So now I'm soooo happy. That's true that I love Ian as a mamber of The Cult very much so it came much more easier to accept him as a
Doors' musician. In Poland where The Cult isn't a famous band people still are not sure about The 21st Doors. But they don't say wrong words about
Ian, rather blame Ray and Robby for they will of money. I find it as a bullshit.
With The Cult whole situation looks much more different, I think, because their vocalist is still ALIVE (thanks God) and replacing him would look much
more strange.
[Edited on 4-4-2003 by Inka]
|
|
|
JayRoberto
Junior Member
Posts: 65
Registered: 12-4-2002
Location: Brusque, SC Brasil
Member Is Offline
|
|
It is not the same situation RAG.
Jim has is dead for 32 years now. Ian is replacing someone who is not able to perform.
Ian is alive and very well, I don't believe Duffy (who would be the only one with powers to do so) would go on as The Cult without Ian. It is more
likely he would start a new band. So would Ian in a reverse situation. Regardless of all the fights and discussions, one can see they share an
enormous respect and friendship for each other.
JRoberto
|
|
|
Homer
Member
Posts: 129
Registered: 3-1-2003
Member Is Offline
|
|
never ...
| Quote: | Originally posted by JayRoberto
I don't believe Duffy would go on as The Cult without Ian. JRoberto |
... we all know for a fact Billy wouldn't replace Ian in The Cult: do you all remember that thing in Sao Paulo in March 1995? When Ian did
quit The Cult? If Billy was going to continue on as "The Cult" with a new singer, he would have done it then but he didn't! When Billy started
"Coloursound", he could have called that "The Cult with new lead singer Mike Peters" but he didn't! So we don't have to worry about Billy and new lead
vocalist ( fill in the blank ) going on as The Cult without Ian ...
|
|
|
JayRoberto
Junior Member
Posts: 65
Registered: 12-4-2002
Location: Brusque, SC Brasil
Member Is Offline
|
|
| Quote: | Originally posted by Homer
| Quote: | Originally posted by JayRoberto
I don't believe Duffy would go on as The Cult without Ian. JRoberto |
... we all know for a fact Billy wouldn't replace Ian in The Cult: do you all remember that thing in Sao Paulo in March 1995? When Ian did
quit The Cult? If Billy was going to continue on as "The Cult" with a new singer, he would have done it then but he didn't! When Billy started
"Coloursound", he could have called that "The Cult with new lead singer Mike Peters" but he didn't! So we don't have to worry about Billy and new lead
vocalist ( fill in the blank ) going on as The Cult without Ian ... |
Good point Homer ! One little correction, the fight in 1995 happened in Rio de Janeiro, Copacaban beach at night...it was kinda romantic :D
JRoberto
|
|
|
sexualpanther3
Senior Member
Posts: 528
Registered: 2-9-2003
Location: Lone Star
Member Is Offline
Mood: hot&bothered
|
|
WHOA WHOA WHOA!!!!
IAN GET REPLACED????? ARE U FUKEN NUTS??? (no offense R.A.G.) the Mighty Duff would never to that to Ian - ever. if he even THOUGHT about it i
think that Ian would do one of two things: sue the hell out of him, or just outright kick his ass. honestly? i call that sorta thing betrayal. on
top of Ian getting on to Billy's case, no doubt in my mind that all the Cult fans in the world would hate him and like a piece of him too. those two
have such a history together, and i personally doubt either one would wanna jeopardize that by replacing the other. dude, they're like brothers
almost!! but thats just my asshole....i mean opinion 
"...., so get on your knees and worship me, worship me." - Black Label Society
"If you really want to commit suicide and you feel that's the only way
out...Try to take someone you hate with you" - Peter Steele
|
|
|
Real Astbury Girrrl
Member
Posts: 132
Registered: 3-12-2003
Member Is Offline
Mood: fuckin bored
|
|
should have clarified....
i was thinking along the same lines as the Morrison situation....if GOD FORBID Ian you know.....(i dont even want to SAY IT)
but YES!! you are right, Duffy has such a respect and loyalty to Ian, its really fuckin cool.
sometims it makes me wonder if Duffy is secretly gay .... ( i am NOT serious) but
you know how in behind the music Duffy was describing ian and him getting back together for BG&E and he goes ..."yeh-it was great....just the two of
us again..." it's pretty funny how he words it.
i know he means it in a brotherly way....i hope! :D
anyway, its totally awesome that they have such a great respect for eachothers talents.....it makes the cult possible thank god!
|
|
|
sexualpanther3
Senior Member
Posts: 528
Registered: 2-9-2003
Location: Lone Star
Member Is Offline
Mood: hot&bothered
|
|
RAG, ur too funny. them two, gay?? then there really WOULD be some two-timin goin on!!
and dont u EVEN think about Ian havin a Jim situation.........we dont wanna jinx our Wolfchild Hipshaker, now do we?
"...., so get on your knees and worship me, worship me." - Black Label Society
"If you really want to commit suicide and you feel that's the only way
out...Try to take someone you hate with you" - Peter Steele
|
|
|
Real Astbury Girrrl
Member
Posts: 132
Registered: 3-12-2003
Member Is Offline
Mood: fuckin bored
|
|
I agree!!
| Quote: | Originally posted by sexualpanther3
RAG, ur too funny. them two, gay?? then there really WOULD be some two-timin goin on!!
and dont u EVEN think about Ian havin a Jim situation.........we dont wanna jinx our Wolfchild Hipshaker, now do we? |
I will NEVER think of THAT. stupid me!
|
|
|
sexualpanther3
Senior Member
Posts: 528
Registered: 2-9-2003
Location: Lone Star
Member Is Offline
Mood: hot&bothered
|
|
good girl - now go over to the Happy Bar and get urself a drink :D
"...., so get on your knees and worship me, worship me." - Black Label Society
"If you really want to commit suicide and you feel that's the only way
out...Try to take someone you hate with you" - Peter Steele
|
|
|
![[*]](images/crimsonflower/default_icon.gif){kind=icon}
